In A Private Dining Room At the Rat Mort
A smudge of crimson lips first catches my attention from across the gallery at the Courtauld. The mouth slants unevenly, giving her expression a certain ambiguity. Grimace or smile? Invitation or rejection? Is her nose wrinkling in disgust or is she beckoning us?
The lips belong to the subject of Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec’s painting, In a Private Dining Room at the Rat Mort (1899)[1]. A strange painting with an odd title, it is at once seductive and unsettling, with an undercurrent of decay.
A woman sits on a red velvet banquette, dressed in layers of smoky gauze; her head seems wrapped in a shawl topped with a bow, much like a gift box. There is a sense that she is on offer. The diagonal downwards brushstrokes guide our attention to a bowl of fruit, among which sits a pear bearing a red highlight that mirrors the woman’s lips. The bowl is the closest object to the viewer, making one wonder: What is Toulouse-Lautrec’s intention? Is it a memento mori? A metaphor for the protagonist’s profession? Overripe fruit are on sale just like prostitutes.
The framing entirely focuses our attention on the prostitute, ruthlessly cropping out anything irrelevant. Although our gaze travels across the canvas, landing briefly on the man seated to her left and the aforementioned fruit bowl below, we are drawn inexorably to the prostitute; her expression, intimidating and snakelike, is magnetic.
Toulouse-Lautrec was a fairly radical painter, even among his Post-Impressionist peers. He depicted Parisian nightlife as he saw it, including the uglier, more vulgar parts of it, in search of beauty. Here, he paints a prostitute, most likely an acquaintance of his, Lucy Jourdain[2], with remarkably ‘compassionate truth’ as Irving Stone described it in his 1950 article in the New York Times.[3]
Looking at this image, I feel deeply uncomfortable yet also intrigued. The toxic green and vulgar red hues, applied with expressionistic brushstrokes, are complementary colours that should clash. And yet Toulouse-Lautrec conjures an unlikely harmony from them, just as he conjures an unlikely tenderness from a sordid scene. It is this same paradox that greeted me across the gallery: a smudge of crimson lips, warring between grimace and invitation, decay and desire. A century on, the painting still refuses to resolve itself, and it was surely this unsettling beauty that Samuel Courtauld recognised when he acquired the work in 1928, choosing to preserve not a comfortable image, but a true one.
References
- [1] Courtauld Gallery Collection Online, In a Private Dining Room (At the Rat Mort), Tête-à-tête Supper. Circa 1899, oil on canvas, Courtauld Gallery, London.
- [2] McDonald, John. “Toulouse-Lautrec & the Moulin Rouge.” John McDonald, 5 Jan. 2013.
- [3] Stone, Irving. “There’s Beauty in the Ugly.” The New York Times, 5 Nov. 1950.